Character Development: ☆☆☆
"Ellie's Deaf boarding school just shut down, forcing her to leave the place she considered home and return to her hearing family. But being mainstreamed into public school isn't exactly easy. So her guidance counselor pairs her with Jackson, a student who's supposed to help her adjust. Can the boy who tries to say the right things, and gets it all wrong, be the lifeline Ellie needs?Jackson has been avoiding his teammates ever since some numbness in his legs cost them an important soccer match. With his senior year off to a lonely start, he's intrigued when he's asked to help the new girl, initially thinking it will be a commendable move on his part. Little does he know Ellie will soon be the person he wants most by his side when the strange symptoms he's experiencing amount to a life-changing diagnosis."
Ellie has been attending a Deaf boarding school since middle school, but when the school closes down her senior year, she suddenly finds herself mainstreaming at the public school her sister attended, and she's rightfully not very happy about it. She has an interpreter with her, at least, but one isn't a great fit, which gets Ellie off to a difficult start on her first day. With some students spreading rumors that she's faking a disability, her parents refusing to learn even basic ASL or use simple accommodations, and her boyfriend of several years breaking up with her basically immediately after their school closed down, Ellie has decided she's just going to ride this year out and then she can move somewhere else and find her own Deaf utopia.
Fortunately, things turn around for her, not just when her guidance counselor pairs her with Jackson to get a tour of the school and be a friendly face, but also because she meets the leader of the school's ASL club and connects with a group of Deaf college freshman that she forms a solid friendship with. As things are turning around for her and her relationship with Jackson is growing, though, things aren't going as well for him.
What started off as a weird tingling sensation in his arms and legs, sort of like they'd fallen asleep, has now expanded to weird haziness in his vision and some vertigo. After a couple of pretty extreme medical emergencies, his parents finally agree to take him to the hospital, where he ends up getting diagnosed with MS. It's a big change, going from an athlete and being super active in school activities, to having limited energy and mobility, and now he has to figure out how these changes will impact his plans for his future.
What I liked about this book: Ellie's friends are all super cool and supportive, as is Jackson's cousin - I wish they had been featured more, and I especially wish that we got to see more from Jackson's family, particularly after the reveal that they have a giant, super active extended family group chat. That was such a wild detail to throw in and then NOT use more!
What I disliked: how repetitive the first three quarters of the book were. It felt like the same point was rehashed over and over, with similar scenes playing out again and again, and then by the time Jackson gets his diagnosis and Ellie really starts to feel more comfortable advocating for herself with her parents the book was almost over and all of that closure was super rushed.
Yes, it sucks that Ellie's school closed and now she's not only in a new school for her last year but it's also a less inclusive environment than she deserves. Yes, it's weird that all of these things are happening to Jackson and confusing that he doesn't know what's causing them. But the interesting part of those things is what happens after. And instead of seeing how Jackson handled going back to school post-diagnosis, instead of seeing how Ellie's relationship with her parents changed after their holiday intervention, we got a couple pages of wrap-up summarizing that they're both in a groove and things are going pretty well, yay! I enjoyed watching Ellie and Jackson's relationship develop, I just wish we could have watched it develop alongside the rest of the story developing with it.
Overall, still a good read. I appreciated the way it took on health not being a guarantee and how anyone can become disabled at anytime. I'm glad Jackson connected with a support group and found ways to adapt to the changes being thrown at him, and I'm glad Ellie was able to carve out a little Deaf happy place with friends she loved and trusted. All told, it was a very hopeful story, I just wish it had a little more meat to it.
No comments:
Post a Comment